What to Expect When Ordering Custom Decorated Cookies from Your Local Bakery in Phoenix
- inaebay
- Jun 26
- 3 min read

If you're planning a celebration and want something sweet, personal, and Instagram-worthy, custom decorated cookies are a perfect choice. Whether you’re hosting a baby shower, birthday, wedding, or corporate event, ordering from a local cookie bakery in Phoenix, Arizona ensures your treats are made with love, care, and creativity.
If you’re new to custom cookies, here’s a step-by-step guide on what to expect when placing your order with a small bakery like Goodies by Max.
1. 🗓️ Book Early – Custom Cookies Take Time
Ordering custom sugar cookies isn’t like grabbing a box from the store. Each cookie is handcrafted with precision, and bakers often book up quickly—especially around holidays or graduation season.
We recommend ordering 2–4 weeks in advance to secure a spot on our calendar. Some months book faster than others, so early planning gives you the best chance of availability.
2. 🎨 Share Your Theme, Colors & Ideas
When placing an order, your baker will ask for:
The occasion (birthday, bridal shower, etc.)
Preferred colors or theme (boho, woodland, Barbie, etc.)
Name, age, date, or logos to include
Reference images or inspiration (Pinterest boards are welcome!)
Your Phoenix cookie artist will design your set to match your vision—no cookie cutters needed (well, some cookie cutters, but lots of creativity too!).
3. 💵 Understand Pricing for Custom Cookies
Most custom cookie orders in Phoenix are priced by the dozen. The more detailed your design (florals, gold accents, character work), the more time and tools it takes, and the price reflects that.
At Goodies by Max, pricing starts at $53/dozen, with a 2-dozen minimum. Every order is made from scratch and decorated by hand.
4. 🚗 Pickup, Local Delivery & Shipping Options
Most custom cookie bakers in Phoenix operate as small businesses—some from licensed home kitchens under the Arizona Cottage Food Program, and others from storefront bakeries. Because of this, pickup and local delivery are the most common options when ordering custom cookies.
At Goodies by Max, we offer pickup in Desert Ridge, Phoenix, and local delivery for large orders like weddings, conferences, or branded corporate gifts (delivery fees may apply).
We do not ship at this time, as Arizona’s Cottage Food Program allows us to serve in-state customers only.
5. 📦 Cookie Packaging & Freshness
Most custom cookie bakers take care to package cookies securely, whether for party favors, gifts, or dessert tables. Packaging may vary by baker, but cookies are often provided in boxes and may be individually wrapped for freshness and convenience.
At Goodies by Max, cookies are individually bagged and heat sealed unless requested otherwise.
✅ In general, decorated sugar cookies stay fresh for 2+ weeks at room temperature and can be frozen for up to 3 months. Just allow them to fully thaw before serving for best results.
6. 💬 Expect Great Communication
Once your custom order is confirmed, you’ll receive:
Order confirmation and details
Payment or invoice reminder (if applicable)
Pickup instructions or delivery timing
A friendly check-in from your baker.
🎉 Custom Cookies Are More Than Dessert
Ordering custom decorated cookies from your local Phoenix bakery adds a heartfelt, personalized touch to your celebration. It’s a fun experience, and you’ll walk away with edible art that’s just as delicious as it is beautiful.
If you're ready to place an order or want to check availability, click here or follow @GoodiesbyMax on Instagram to see past designs and class info.
Comments